COSTA MESA CITY COUNCIL MEETS TUESDAY, AND FIPAC WILL HOLD A SPECIAL MEETING ON WEDNESDAY
City Council to consider Measure K Zoning Code Amendments and Zoning Map Updates, along with Revised Agreements for Senior Center Affordable Housing Project
🏛️ CITY COUNCIL MEETING. The Costa Mesa City Council and the Costa Mesa Housing Authority will meet next Tuesday, November 17, 2026.
This agenda is short, and it should have been longer. The City postponed the Fairview Park Master Plan Update (FPMPU) public hearing, which had been scheduled for this meeting. The delay follows a November 2 meeting involving Staff, the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW), and the Harbor Soaring Society regarding CDFW's notice requiring the cessation of operations at the existing west-side flying field.
During that meeting, the parties discussed regulatory options and possible alternatives for the flying field. As a result, City leadership decided it needs additional time to evaluate these issues before moving forward with the FPMPU. The FPMPU will now be considered at a 2027 meeting.
This will be the last meeting for the four City Council members who are being term-out. The next meeting on December 1 will be when the new City Council will be seated.
📅 Date & Time: Tuesday, November 17, 2026, at 6:00 p.m.
🔒 Closed Session begins at 4:00 p.m.
📍 Location: City Council Chambers, 77 Fair Drive
📄 Agenda: Available here.
🔒CLOSED SESSION: Nine items are scheduled for discussion:
Anticipated litigation, one case. Someone is threatening to sue the City. What now?
Existing litigation, eight (8) cases:
Three involving D’Alessio;
One brought by Disability Rights California;
One involving the State of California over our noncompliant Housing Element;
One personal injury lawsuit filed by Zoe Percival that originated in 2024; and
One lawsuit filed by Jim Fitzpatrick and his consulting company Touchpoint Services, Inc.
In the Fitzpatrick case, the Plaintiffs have sued the City, former City Manager Lori Ann Farrell Harrison, former Finance Director Carol Molina, and City Attorney Kim Hall Barlow. The lawsuit alleges that City officials retaliated against Fitzpatrick for publicly criticizing City government by discouraging others from hiring him or working with his consulting business.
According to the complaint, the basis for the retaliation claim is:
Protected speech: Fitzpatrick alleges he regularly spoke at City Council meetings, participated in civic forums, and published his "GOAT" newsletter, in which he criticized permitting delays, City spending, transparency, cannabis tax revenue, and permit processes.
Alleged retaliation: The complaint claims that in April 2024, Finance Department Manager Carol Molina told Lisa Price of Priceless Pets that she would not receive an animal shelter conditional use permit if she hired Fitzpatrick as a consultant. Price subsequently chose not to retain him.
Continuing conduct: The lawsuit further alleges that in October 2026, City Attorney Kim Hall Barlow advised another client's attorney not to work with Fitzpatrick because doing so would impede results. The complaint also alleges that former City Manager Lori Ann Farrell Harrison directed, authorized, knew of, or allowed efforts to discourage third parties from doing business with him.
Alleged harm: Plaintiffs contend that these actions were motivated by Fitzpatrick's criticism of the City and would discourage a reasonable person from engaging in similar protected speech. They claim damages including lost consulting opportunities, fewer Costa Mesa clients, reputational harm, emotional distress, and a chilling effect on free speech.
Legal Claims: The lawsuit's retaliation-related claims include:
First Amendment retaliation (42 U.S.C. § 1983): Alleging that City officials took adverse actions against Fitzpatrick because of his protected speech.
Municipal liability (Monell claim): Alleging that the City is liable because senior officials either directed, approved, failed to stop, or allowed the alleged conduct to occur.
Related state-law claims: Including interference with contractual relations, interference with prospective economic advantage, and violation of the California Bane Act based on alleged threats, intimidation, or coercion.
Important: These allegations are claims made by the Plaintiffs in the lawsuit. They have not been proven in court, and no findings of fact have been made regarding whether the alleged conduct occurred.
🏛️ REGULAR SESSION: No presentations are scheduled.
🎤PUBLIC COMMENTS: This is the time for YOU to comment for THREE FREE minutes on ANYTHING that is not on the agenda.
📌 IMPORTANT! WRITTEN PUBLIC COMMENTS AND VISUAL PRESENTATIONS MUST BE SUBMITTED BY NOON TO BE SCREENED AND PUBLISHED ON THE CITY'S WEBSITE.
🗂️CONSENT CALENDAR: Most consent items are routine, but these warrant a closer look:
Item 3, Adoption of Warrant Resolution:
$111,467.13 was paid to the City Attorney, Jones Mayer, yet the legal invoices listed on the register are not itemized. This lack of transparency is unacceptable. The City receives detailed billing from its outside counsel, but the public cannot see how these taxpayer dollars are being spent. Without itemized billing, neither the City Council nor residents can evaluate whether legal expenditures are reasonable or whether litigation costs have exceeded the value of the matter being litigated. Greater transparency and public disclosure of legal expenses are needed.
The payment above is in addition to $38,043.00 paid to Liebert Cassidy Whitmore for human resources-related legal services and $14,659.00 paid to Everett Dorey, both of which also appear without itemized billing available to the public.
There is also an unitemized charge through U.S. Bank associated with Mayor Pro Tem Manuel Chavez that appears related to attendance at the League of California Cities Conference in September. To date, the public has not received a report on his participation, including how he voted on the Murrieta Resolution, which called for a statewide, city-led effort to evaluate options for strengthening local authority over housing and land-use decisions. Because taxpayer funds paid for this trip, residents deserve an accounting of the benefits received and how their representative voted on this significant policy issue.
Another payment of $66,625.93 was made to PlaceWorks, the consultant that prepared the Fairview Developmental Center Specific Plan. As discussed under Old Business Item 1, the plan failed to include affordable housing language required by the State, resulting in a strongly worded response from the Department of Housing and Community Development. Given the significance of that omission, I would have questioned this invoice before payment. Unfortunately, the City has already paid the bill.
Item 4, Minutes: Eight sets of draft meeting minutes covering May through October are awaiting approval. Allowing meeting minutes to accumulate for months is not good practice. The longer the delay, the harder it becomes for Councilmembers, Staff, and the public to accurately recall the discussions, decisions, and direction from those meetings. Minutes should be brought forward for approval more promptly. I will have to compare them against the reports in the Costa Mesa First blog. 😊
Item 10, Resolution Authorizing Staff to Apply For Statewide Park Development and Community Revitalization Program for Shalimar Park. Staff is requesting authorization to apply for a grant of up to $4 million through California's Statewide Park Development and Community Revitalization Program to design, engineer, and construct a community center as part of Phase II of the Shalimar Park expansion project. In addition to the community center, the proposal includes an outdoor gathering space with shade structures, a multi-use sports court, outdoor fitness equipment, and additional open lawn area. The application deadline is December 17, 2026.
I have no objection to pursuing grant funding for this project. However, I do question why a potential $4 million project is being placed on the Consent Calendar. Projects of this magnitude deserve a public discussion and individual consideration by the City Council, rather than being grouped with routine administrative items.
I am also concerned that the Agenda Report provides no assessment of the City's likelihood of receiving this highly competitive grant. While $188.5 million is available statewide, the report does not discuss the factors that may affect Costa Mesa's competitiveness.
One factor to address is the City's ongoing lack of a state-certified Housing Element. As we have already seen with funding challenges related to the Senior Center Housing Project. Non-compliance with state housing requirements can have real consequences when seeking state funding. Before investing Staff time and resources into this application, the City Council and the public should have a clearer understanding of the City's chances of success and whether our current housing compliance issues could affect the outcome.

📑PUBLIC HEARINGS: None.
🕰️OLD BUSINESS: There are two items:
1. Adoption of Ordinance for Measure K Zoning Code Amendments and Zoning Map Updates. Staff recommends adopting the ordinance that implements the final zoning and map changes associated with the Measure K/Neighborhoods Where We All Belong (NWWAB) housing initiative. The ordinance makes extensive amendments to Title 13 of the Municipal Code and the City's Zoning Map in order to implement the Housing Element, comply with state housing law, and help accommodate Costa Mesa's Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) requirement of 11,760 housing units.
The ordinance includes technical changes to mixed-use development standards, parking regulations, signage requirements, construction-hour waiver procedures, density bonus provisions, and housing regulations at the Fairview Developmental Center.
The Most Significant Change Involves the Fairview Developmental Center. One of the most consequential provisions affects future affordable housing projects at Fairview Developmental Center (FDC).
Under the ordinance, projects located on designated RHNA housing sites at the FDC that provide at least 20 percent of their units for lower-income households must be processed ministerially, or "by right," provided they comply with applicable objective standards and state housing law.
What does that mean in practice? It means qualifying projects would no longer be subject to discretionary review by the Planning Commission or City Council. The City would be limited to determining whether the project complies with objective development standards. If it does, the City must approve the project.
The City could not:
Reduce the proposed density.
Impose additional discretionary conditions.
Deny the project based on subjective concerns.
Apply the traditional Planning Commission and City Council review process.
The ordinance further requires that the RHNA sites remain capable of accommodating the housing density promised to the State, including residential development at a minimum density of 20 dwelling units per acre and mixed-use projects with at least 50 percent residential floor area.
In effect, the ordinance limits local discretion and creates a more streamlined path for affordable housing development on portions of the Fairview Developmental Center property.
An Important Unanswered Question. This raises a significant question regarding the City's previously adopted limit of 2,300 dwelling units at the Fairview Developmental Center.
If state law requires the site to maintain sufficient development capacity to meet lower-income RHNA obligations, can the City realistically enforce that 2,300-unit cap in the future?
I am skeptical.
A future developer could point to these provisions and argue that the City must allow greater density to satisfy state housing requirements. That argument may be strengthened by the fact that the Environmental Impact Report analyzed up to 4,000 residential units and that the City Council ultimately certified that EIR.
Whether the 2,300-unit limitation will withstand future legal or regulatory scrutiny remains an open question.
What the Agenda Report Does Not Discuss. Equally concerning is what the Agenda Report omits.
The report does not discuss two recent letters from the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) that were included elsewhere in the meeting Agenda. The letters can be read by clicking on these links:
The November 10, 2026 HCD letter acknowledges that the City has addressed previously identified deficiencies regarding housing capacity and rezoning requirements, particularly as they relate to the Fairview Developmental Center Specific Plan. However, HCD makes clear that the City Council must still formally adopt those corrective actions.
More importantly, HCD also states that Costa Mesa's Housing Element remains noncompliant.
According to HCD, the City must continue implementing and reporting on numerous housing programs and must address unresolved barriers affecting housing opportunities for people with disabilities. Specifically, HCD found that the City's zoning regulations continue to contain provisions that may impede housing for individuals with disabilities and urged the City to promptly revise its reasonable accommodation, single-housekeeping-unit, and group-home regulations.
HCD further reminds the City that it retains the authority to review local actions and may revoke a finding of substantial compliance if adequate progress is not made, especially on disability-related zoning barriers.
Why This Matters. The Agenda Report's complete silence on these HCD concerns is troubling.
For months, I have raised concerns that the City has not treated these disability-related housing issues with the urgency they deserve. The latest correspondence from HCD suggests these concerns remain unresolved and that the State is becoming increasingly frustrated by the City's lack of progress.
Before adopting sweeping zoning changes under the NWWAB initiative, the City Council should publicly acknowledge that the Housing Element remains out of compliance and clearly explain how and when it intends to address the remaining deficiencies HCD identified.
The public deserves a complete picture of where the City stands with the State, not just the portions of the story that support approval of the ordinance.
2. Revised Ground Lease, Revised Regulatory Agreement, Density Bonus Regulatory Agreement, and Loan Agreements for Approved 70-Unit Senior Affordable Housing Project on Portion of Senior Center Parking Lot and Associated Agreements. Staff is requesting approval of a series of revised agreements needed to move forward with construction of the 70-unit senior affordable housing project on a portion of the Senior Center parking lot. These actions include revised ground lease and regulatory agreements, loan documents, lender subordination agreements, a RHNA credit-transfer agreement with Orange County, and related financing documents.
Why This Matters. The primary purpose of these agreements is to satisfy lender and tax-credit investor requirements so the project can close on its financing package and begin construction. If these agreements are not approved, the project would likely miss its December 2026 construction closing and could jeopardize critical funding sources.
Project Overview. The project consists of a four-story, 93,972-square-foot senior housing development on a newly created 1.5-acre parcel at the Senior Center site. The development will include:
70 total units, consisting of 69 affordable senior apartments and one manager's unit.
34 units for low-income seniors earning up to 60% of Area Median Income (AMI).
35 permanent supportive housing units for very-low-income seniors earning up to 30% of AMI.
Supportive services include case management, financial counseling, and employment assistance.
The project also received a State Density Bonus that increased the unit count from the original to 70, along with concessions related to open space, setbacks, and parking standards.
Funding Structure. The City previously approved $3.25 million in gap financing, consisting of:
$1.15 million in HOME funds, and
$2.1 million in ARPA-funded Housing Trust Fund money.
Since that approval, Jamboree Housing Corporation has secured Low-Income Housing Tax Credits expected to generate approximately $27 million in tax-credit equity for the project.
What Happened With Alternative Funding? One question that has lingered since the City approved its financial contribution earlier this year is whether Jamboree could reduce City funding by securing additional outside funding.
The answer appears to be mixed.
Jamboree successfully secured the tax-credit financing, a major funding source for the project. However, its efforts to replace or reduce the City's financial commitment through other grants and financing programs were unsuccessful.
According to the Agenda Report, Jamboree pursued several additional funding opportunities, including charitable housing grants and financing programs administered through the Federal Home Loan Bank. Those efforts did not result in additional funding.
One notable obstacle was that the City's ground lease structure requires additional rent payments, which reportedly made the project less competitive for one of the financing programs Jamboree pursued.
RHNA Credit Transfer. The proposal also includes an agreement with Orange County that would transfer credit for four Seventh-Cycle RHNA units to Costa Mesa, including:
One very-low-income unit, and
Three moderate-income units.
The transfer remains subject to State and regional approval.
Bottom Line. This item is largely about finalizing the financing and legal framework necessary to begin construction. Jamboree secured approximately $27 million in tax-credit equity, but it could not secure enough alternative funding to reduce the City's previously approved financial commitment. As a result, the City's contribution remains a necessary component of the project's financing package and its ability to move forward.

🆕NEW BUSINESS: None.
🎤PUBLIC PARTICIPATION: Do not forget! You get three FREE minutes of public comment on anything not on the Agenda at the beginning of the meeting, and three FREE minutes on any of the agendized items.
📌 IMPORTANT! WRITTEN PUBLIC COMMENTS AND VISUAL PRESENTATIONS MUST BE SUBMITTED BY NOON TO BE REVIEWED AND PUBLISHED ON THE CITY'S WEBSITE.
💵 FINANCE AND PENSION ADVISORY COMMITTEE (FiPAC) SPECIAL MEETING. The regular meeting scheduled for earlier this month was canceled, so the Committee must hold a Special meeting
📅 Wednesday, November 18, 2026
⏰ 4:00 p.m.
📍 City Hall, Community Room, 77 Fair Drive
🔗 Agenda: Available here.
Other than the draft Minutes for the September 9, 2026 regular meeting, no Agenda Reports have been made available to the public.
Several agenda items are described so vaguely that it is impossible to determine what actions are being proposed or what their impact may be. This undermines the public's ability to participate in the decision-making process and raises serious questions about compliance with the Brown Act's notice requirements. The Brown Act is meant to ensure transparency and informed public participation, and that purpose is not served when agenda descriptions fail to meaningfully disclose the subject matter under consideration.
Here are the key agenda items:
Receive a Bond Measure update.
Review the Overtime Report, including discussion, public comment, and recommendations for City Council.
Conduct the FY 2026/27 first-quarter budget review, also with discussion, public comment, and potential City Council recommendations.
🎤 Public Participation: Speak Up! You get three FREE minutes to comment during the public comment period.
🛑 Important! You MUST attend in person at 77 Fair Drive. The meeting is NOT on Zoom, livestreamed, or recorded. You must attend in person.

Comments